Freemium vs Free Trial: PLG Strategy Guide

Explore the differences between freemium and free trial models to enhance your Product-Led Growth strategy and boost conversion rates.
Picture of Lillian Pierson, P.E.

Lillian Pierson, P.E.

Reading Time: 7 minutes

Freemium and free trials are two key strategies for Product-Led Growth (PLG). Here’s a quick breakdown:

  • Freemium offers basic features for free, attracting a large audience but with lower conversion rates (average 7%). It’s great for crowded markets and products with viral potential.
  • Free Trials provide full access for a limited time, leading to higher conversion rates (up to 50% with credit card trials) but a smaller initial user base. Best for complex products with immediate value.

Quick Comparison

Aspect Freemium Free Trial
Conversion Rate 1–10% 30–50% (with credit card)
User Base Larger, less qualified Smaller, more qualified
Market Fit Crowded markets Niche or complex products
Support Costs Higher ongoing costs Limited to trial period
User Commitment No urgency to upgrade Creates urgency
Revenue Impact Slower growth Faster initial results

Which should you choose?

  • Go freemium if your product is simple, thrives on network effects, or targets a large market.
  • Opt for a free trial if your product is complex, delivers fast value, or targets high-intent users.

The right choice depends on your product, market, and long-term growth goals.

Free Trial vs Freemium – Use the MOAT Framework to Decide

1. How Freemium Works

Freemium models offer basic features at no cost while charging for advanced options. Popular platforms like Dropbox and Slack have successfully used this approach. Here’s how the model typically operates:

1. Value-Based Feature Segmentation
Freemium works by offering enough value in the free tier to attract users, while reserving premium features as an incentive to upgrade. For example, Dropbox provides 2 GB of free storage to its over 700 million users, resulting in a 2.5% paid conversion rate .

2. Usage-Driven Conversion
Usage limits often encourage users to upgrade. Slack, for instance, restricts free accounts to a 90-day message history. This strategy has helped Slack achieve a 30% conversion rate. Across SaaS, conversion rates generally range from 6–10% for small-business B2B and 2–5% overall .

3. Continuous Improvement and Support
To succeed, freemium models require ongoing updates and strong infrastructure. Spotify excels here by providing a compelling free experience that naturally leads users to its premium tier .

"Freemium is like a Samurai sword: unless you’re a master at using it, you can cut your arm off." – Rob Walling

Tips for Effective Freemium Implementation

To make freemium work, companies should focus on these strategies:

  • Design personalized onboarding to quickly show users the value of the product.
  • Use well-timed upgrade prompts based on user behavior.
  • Analyze usage patterns to identify key features and set effective limits .

Keep in mind that optimizing a freemium model can take 12–18 months and requires significant investment . LinkedIn is a great example of scaling this model successfully, with nearly 500 million users and one in five million subscribing to premium features .

Key Metrics Industry Average
Visitor to Free User 13.7%
Free to Paid Conversion 3.7%
Time to Optimization 12–18 months
Support Cost per Free User Higher than paid

The freemium approach works best when companies address core user needs first and then create clear pathways to premium features. This strategy helps grow a broad user base while ensuring a steady flow of paid subscribers. Next, we’ll dive into free trial strategies and how they differ in driving conversions.

2. How Free Trials Work

Free trials let users experience the full product for a limited time, giving them a chance to explore its features without committing. These trials often lead to higher conversion rates than freemium models .

Trial Structure and Performance

Free trials stand out from freemium models by offering immediate access to all features. They generally come in two formats:

  • No Credit Card Required: Conversion rates range from low single digits up to 25% .
  • Credit Card Required: Conversion rates are higher, typically ranging from 30% to 50% .

Opt-out trials, where users are automatically enrolled unless they cancel, deliver strong results. These models see conversion rates of 48.8% from organic traffic and 51% from paid traffic .

Implementation Strategy

To make free trials successful, delivering value quickly is key. For example, Snappa removed the email activation step during onboarding, which increased their monthly recurring revenue (MRR) by 20% . Simplifying the onboarding process reduces friction and keeps users engaged.

Trial Type Conversion Metrics per 1,000 Website Visits
Free Trial 30 sign-ups → 5.1 paid customers
Freemium 60 sign-ups → 3 paid customers
ROI Difference 70% higher paid conversion yield

Key Success Factors

  1. Personalized Onboarding
    Customize the onboarding experience for different user groups. Kontentino, for instance, boosted new user activation by 10% with an interactive walkthrough using Userpilot .
  2. Show Value Quickly
    Help users achieve their goals as soon as possible. Rocketbots saw their activation rate jump from 15% to 30% by adding an interactive walkthrough .
  3. Keep Users Engaged
    Provide ongoing guidance and support during the trial so users can easily explore key features and hit important milestones.

Monitoring Performance

Track these metrics to evaluate your free trial’s success:

  • Activation rate (industry average: 6.8% by day seven)
  • Time to activation
  • Free-to-paid conversion rate
  • Monthly recurring revenue (MRR) from trial users
  • Customer lifetime value (LTV)

Free trials work especially well for complex products in less crowded markets , as they encourage users to fully engage with all features and learn the product thoroughly. This aligns with the Product-Led Growth (PLG) approach of driving quick engagement and delivering value early.

sbb-itb-e8c8399

Benefits and Drawbacks

When using the PLG framework, it’s important to weigh the trade-offs of each model. For example, trials have seen a drop in market share from around 40% to 20% .

Aspect Freemium Free Trial
Conversion Rate Lower (1–10%) Higher (30–50% with credit card)
User Base Larger, less qualified Smaller, more qualified
Market Entry Better for crowded markets Best for complex products
Support Costs Higher ongoing costs Limited to trial period
User Commitment No pressure to convert Creates urgency
Revenue Impact Slower but steady growth Faster initial results

These factors highlight the strengths and challenges of each model.

Key Advantages

Freemium model advantages:

  • Encourages viral growth through shareability
  • Builds long-term presence via word-of-mouth
  • Allows users to explore basic features at their own pace
  • Works effectively in highly competitive markets

Free trial advantages:

  • Creates urgency, boosting conversion rates
  • Attracts more serious, high-intent users
  • Works best for products with clear differentiation

Real-World Impact

The competition between Atlassian and Slack from 2017 to 2019 offers a great example. Atlassian’s Stride used a trial-based model but struggled to compete with Slack’s freemium strategy. This led Atlassian to sell Stride to Slack and later introduce free tiers across its cloud products.

"The right choice between a free plan vs. trial entirely depends on the nature of your product and market as opposed to your target conversion rate. This is what makes it a strategic choice."

Implementation Challenges

Despite their benefits, both models come with challenges.

Freemium challenges:

  • Ongoing costs for supporting free users can be high
  • Risks losing revenue by giving away too much for free
  • Needs a massive user base (about 50 million active users) to succeed

Free trial challenges:

  • Less effective for products requiring in-depth training
  • May fail to deliver enough value quickly
  • Can strain customer support teams during trial periods
  • Often leads to unsustainable short-term gains

Vidyard provides a compelling example of adapting to these challenges. After struggling with low conversion rates from a 30-day free trial, the company introduced a free Chrome extension in 2017. This freemium approach brought in over 100,000 users within a year, showing how the right model can drive adoption (Source: ProductLed, 2024).

Understanding these benefits and obstacles is crucial for selecting the right model, which will be explored further in later sections.

How to Pick the Right Model

Choosing between freemium and free trial models depends on several key factors. Let’s break it down.

Market Position Assessment

Your market position plays a major role in deciding the right approach. Freemium works better in crowded markets, while free trials are ideal when your product’s unique value stands out .

Freemium models require a massive user base to succeed. Jason Lemkin of SaaStr highlights this, stating you need about 50 million active users to build a $100 million business . On the other hand, free trials are better suited for smaller markets with higher conversion rates – 10–25% compared to freemium’s 5% .

Product Characteristics

The nature of your product also influences the choice. Here’s a quick comparison:

Factor Freemium Works Best When Free Trial Works Best When
Complexity Product is simple and easy to use Product has complex features needing guidance
Time to Value Value builds gradually over time Benefits are immediately apparent
Cost to Serve Low cost per user High cost per user
Network Effects Strong potential for viral growth Limited reliance on network effects
User Type General end-users with basic needs Niche users with specialized needs

The MOAT Framework

The MOAT framework can help you evaluate your options systematically :

  • Market Strategy: Are you competing in a crowded (Red Ocean) or untapped (Blue Ocean) market? Freemium often works better in crowded spaces where early traction is key.
  • Ocean Conditions: In highly competitive markets, freemium can help secure users early on.
  • Audience: Think about your users’ motivation and technical skills. Low motivation means your product must be extremely easy to use.
  • Time-to-Value: How quickly can users see real benefits? This is especially crucial for free trials.

Warning Signs

Neither model may be ideal if your product is too complex for self-service, targets highly qualified leads, or struggles to sustain free users.

Hybrid Approaches

A hybrid model could be the answer. For example, you might offer full access initially and then transition users to a freemium tier . This combines the urgency of a free trial with the long-term engagement of freemium, giving you the best of both worlds.

Key Decision Drivers

Here’s when to choose each model:

Freemium is better when:

  • Your product thrives on network effects.
  • Marginal costs per user are low.
  • There’s a clear path for users to upgrade.
  • Self-service onboarding is effective.
  • Your market size is large enough to support massive user acquisition.

Free Trial is better when:

  • Your product shows value immediately.
  • You’re targeting a smaller, niche market.
  • Educating customers is essential.
  • Higher conversion rates are critical.
  • Support costs per user are substantial.

Josh Kopelman from First Round Capital puts it perfectly:

"Scaling from $5 to $50 million is not the toughest part of a new venture – it’s getting your users to pay you anything at all. The biggest gap in any venture is that between a service that is free and one that costs a penny."

These insights will help guide your decision, setting the foundation for your next steps.

Conclusion

Choosing between freemium and free trial models plays a key role in shaping your product-led growth (PLG) strategy. These models serve different purposes, with conversion rates generally around 5% for freemium and 10–25% for free trials .

For businesses aiming to quickly gain traction in competitive markets, freemium can be an effective starting point. On the other hand, free trials shine for more complex software. For instance, Autodesk built a $5 billion enterprise by offering 15-day free trials followed by subscriptions, demonstrating the power of this approach .

"The right choice between a free plan vs. trial entirely depends on the nature of your product and market as opposed to your target conversion rate. This is what makes it a strategic choice. The right strategy needs to maximize your long-term revenue growth as a company, not short-term sign-up and activation rates."

This highlights the importance of focusing on long-term revenue growth rather than short-term metrics like sign-ups or activations.

To succeed, you must align your model with factors such as product complexity, market size, pricing strategy, user acquisition goals, and available support resources. Companies like PandaDoc and Vidyard demonstrate how thoughtful execution can make all the difference. Their success stems from prioritizing user experience, clearly communicating trial terms, and strategically dividing features between free and paid tiers .

Whether you go with freemium or a free trial, the priority should always be delivering value that encourages users to convert into paying customers. The ultimate goal remains clear: provide undeniable value to turn users into loyal advocates.

Related Blog Posts

Share Now:
HI, I’M LILLIAN PIERSON.
I’m a growth advisor and fractional CMO that architects strategies that drive 10x more growth from the marketing foundations you already have.
Apply To Work Together
If you’re looking for marketing strategy and leadership support with a proven track record of driving breakthrough growth for tech startups across all industries and business models, you’re in the right place. Over the last decade, I’ve supported the growth of 30% of Fortune 10 companies, and more tech startups than you can shake a stick at. I stay very busy, but I’m currently able to accommodate a handful of select new clients. Visit this page to learn more about how I can help you and to book a time for us to speak directly.
Get Featured
We love helping tech brands gain exposure and brand awareness among our audience of 750,000 tech workers. If you’d like to explore our alternatives for brand partnerships and content collaborations, you can reach out directly on this page and book a time to speak.
Join The Convergence Newsletter
Join The Convergence and see the best practices that thousands of tech founders, startup execs, and growth leaders are leveraging to scale smarter. Get proven growth strategies, data-backed marketing playbooks, and executive-level insights – All exclusively shared to this free community of builders who are turning strategy into revenue.

Subscribe now.
HI, I’M LILLIAN PIERSON.
I’m a fractional CMO that specializes in go-to-market and product-led growth for B2B tech companies.
Apply To Work Together
If you’re looking for marketing strategy and leadership support with a proven track record of driving breakthrough growth for B2B tech startups and consultancies, you’re in the right place. Over the last decade, I’ve supported the growth of 30% of Fortune 10 companies, and more tech startups than you can shake a stick at. I stay very busy, but I’m currently able to accommodate a handful of select new clients. Visit this page to learn more about how I can help you and to book a time for us to speak directly.
Get Featured
We love helping tech brands gain exposure and brand awareness among our active audience of 530,000 data professionals. If you’d like to explore our alternatives for brand partnerships and content collaborations, you can reach out directly on this page and book a time to speak.
Join The Convergence Newsletter
See what 26,000 other data professionals have discovered from the powerful data science, AI, and data strategy advice that’s only available inside this free community newsletter.
By subscribing you agree to Substack’s Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy and our Information collection notice